Current:Home > ContactOfficers need warrants to use aircraft, zoom lenses to surveil areas around homes, Alaska court says -GrowthInsight
Officers need warrants to use aircraft, zoom lenses to surveil areas around homes, Alaska court says
TrendPulse Quantitative Think Tank Center View
Date:2025-04-06 13:48:48
JUNEAU, Alaska (AP) — Alaska law enforcement officers must obtain a warrant before using aircraft to scope out the area around a person’s home with binoculars or cameras with zoom lenses, the state’s highest court ruled in a decision released Friday.
The Alaska Supreme Court ruling comes in a case that dates to 2012, when Alaska State Troopers received a tip from an informant that John William McKelvey III was growing marijuana on his property in a sparsely populated area north of Fairbanks.
According to the ruling, McKelvey’s property was heavily wooded, with a driveway leading to a clearing where a house and greenhouse were located. Trees blocked the ground-level view of the buildings from outside the clearing, and a gate blocked cars from entering.
In the court’s recounting of the case, two troopers, following up on the tip, flew past the property and used a camera with a high-power zoom lens to take photos that showed buckets containing “unidentifiable plants” inside the greenhouse. Based on the tip and flight observations, a search warrant for McKelvey’s property was obtained. During the search, officers found items including marijuana plants, methamphetamine, scales, a rifle and cash.
McKelvey sought to have the evidence suppressed, but a Superior Court judge denied that.
He was convicted of one court of third-degree misconduct involving a controlled substance and a weapons misconduct count. He appealed, arguing the judge wrongly denied his motion to suppress.
An appeals court reversed the Superior Court judge, and the Supreme Court affirmed the appeals court decision in its ruling released Friday.
The state maintained “that because small airplane travel is so common in Alaska, and because any passenger might peer into your yard and snap a picture of you, law enforcement officials may do the same. We disagree,” the Alaska Supreme Court decision states.
“The Alaska Constitution protects the right to be free of unreasonable searches,” the ruling states. “The fact that a random person might catch a glimpse of your yard while flying from one place to another does not make it reasonable for law enforcement officials to take to the skies and train high-powered optics on the private space right outside your home without a warrant.”
Law enforcement officers must obtain a warrant before using aircraft and “vision-enhancing technology,” such as cameras with zoom lenses or binoculars, to surveil the area surrounding a person’s home that is protected from ground-level observation, the court said.
Most land in Alaska is not considered “curtilage of the home, where the right to privacy is strongest. Therefore authorities are not necessarily restricted from using aircraft and vision-enhancing technology to surveil those areas,” the court said. Curtilage refers to the area in and around a home.
Robert John, an attorney for McKelvey, called the ruling a “tremendous decision to protect the rights of privacy of Alaskans and hopefully set an example for the rest of the country.”
The Department of Law did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment.
veryGood! (7356)
Related
- Sam Taylor
- Suki Waterhouse Makes Rare Comment About Bradley Cooper Break Up
- Badminton Star Zhang Zhijie Dead At 17 After Collapsing On Court During Match
- USA TODAY Editor-in-Chief Terence Samuel leaves Gannett after one year
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Triathlon
- Chet Hanks Reveals Cokeheads Advised Him to Chill Amid Addiction Battle
- Despite vows of safety from OnlyFans, predators are exploiting kids on the platform
- Hawaii teachers say they want to prioritize civic education — but they need more help
- Taylor Swift makes surprise visit to Kansas City children’s hospital
- Caitlin Clark in action: How to watch Indiana Fever vs. Las Vegas Aces on Tuesday
Ranking
- Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
- The Kid Laroi goes Instagram official with Tate McRae in honor of singer's birthday
- Melting of Alaska’s Juneau icefield accelerates, losing snow nearly 5 times faster than in the 1980s
- Environmental groups decry attempt to delay shipping rules intended to save whales
- The FBI should have done more to collect intelligence before the Capitol riot, watchdog finds
- Oklahoma St RB Ollie Gordon II, who won Doak Walker Award last season, arrested for suspicion of DUI
- AccuWeather: False Twitter community notes undermined Hurricane Beryl forecast, warnings
- Ticketmaster confirms data breach, won't say how many North American customers compromised
Recommendation
Toyota to invest $922 million to build a new paint facility at its Kentucky complex
Arby's brings back potato cakes for first time since 2021
Supreme Court refuses to hear bite mark case
Jeffrey Epstein secret transcripts: Victim was asked, Do you know 'you committed a crime?'
Why we love Bear Pond Books, a ski town bookstore with a French bulldog 'Staff Pup'
'Guiding Light' actor and model Renauld White dies at 80
Suki Waterhouse Reveals Whether She and Robert Pattinson Planned Pregnancy
The Daily Money: CDK outage draws to a close